Digitizing a Code of Ordinance but less worse
Municode is atrocious like all government software.
I’ve been doing some data sleuthing the past few months on my hometown and have felt the pains of interacting with government software or really the lack thereof. I read this recent blog post about legal exploitation in German law and wanted to do the same for my city’s legal documents. Laredo establishes a charter which enumerates the rights of the municipal government. The council passes laws known as ordinances which are then codified into the Code of Ordinances.
It turns out a lot of local governments have migrated to Municode. It’s really a glorified site to host legal documents…so a Wikipedia but worse. It is such a specimen of a site - absurdly slow response speeds, bulky payloads, and frankly an underwhelming UI. Remember this is just text, hyperlinks, and diffs!
One day I hope that local leaders will take a good look at their software stack and ask can we do better (e.g. Estonia’s e-government). For Municode’s legal repository, I would expect the bare minimum
- No slow websites please.
- Be able to see edits, when they were approved, who approved them, etc.
- An API for tech savvy citizens.
On a related note, I have also been interested in permits, traffic, potholes, etc. Lo and behold all of the software is fractured and slow, the data is not available or requires manual uploads, and occasionally one has to go through Public Information requests to get what should be considered public data. This fosters deception by conveniently suppressing communication to and from residents and results in unecessary bloat, delays, and lies by elected leaders. This is true insanity.
Anyways, I downloaded the ordinances and created git histories for the Charter and Code of Ordinances. There isn’t really much to comment about since it’s not that technically interesting. I don’t think that using git version control is the best interface for public affairs, but it is 1000% better than whatever pile of doo Municode is.